Progress in Electrocatalytic Oxygen Precipitation Reaction under Neutral Environment

doi:10.12422/j.issn.1006-396X.2023.05.001

Abstract

Abstract:

The development of clean and renewable energy technologies is seen as the key to addressing energy and environmental issues.Oxygen evolution reaction (OER) plays key roles in storage intermittent energy,such as solar and wind,from water splitting.Recently, OER under neutral conditions receives considerable interests due to its environmental friendliness.However,the efficiency of OER under neutral environment is far below that under alkaline or acidic condition.In this review,the current researchers' understanding of the mechanism of OER under mild pH conditions is firstly outlined.Thereafter,several important characterisation techniques for in situ tracking of the electrocatalytic process of OER are presented,which is crucial to reveal the OER mechanism under neutral conditions.Moreover,an overview over catalytic materials towards neutral OER,including Co?,Ni?,and Mn?based catalysts,is provided.Finally,a brief outlook on the remaining challenges and possible strategies for promoting neutral OER is given.

Key words: Electrocatalysis, Oxygen evolution reaction（OER）, In situ characterization, Neutral water electrolysis

摘要：

清洁和可再生能源技术的发展被视为解决能源和环境问题的关键。电催化分解水过程中的析氧反应（OER）在太阳能和风能等间歇式能源存储方面发挥着关键作用。环境友好的中性环境下的OER受到了很大的关注，然而其电解水析氧效率远低于在碱性或酸性条件下电解水析氧效率。基于此，首先概括了目前研究者对中性环境下OER机理的认识；介绍了几种重要的原位跟踪OER电催化过程的表征技术，并概述了包括Co基、Ni基和Mn基等中性环境下的OER催化材料；最后，对促进中性环境下电催化分解水OER面临的挑战进行了总结，并提出了可能的解决策略。

关键词: 电催化, 析氧反应, 原位表征, 中性电解水

CLC Number:

TQ151.1

Kun DU, Jiaxin GUO, Ziang MA, Jing MAO, Tao LING, Wei ZHAO. Progress in Electrocatalytic Oxygen Precipitation Reaction under Neutral Environment[J]. Journal of Petrochemical Universities, 2023, 36(5): 1-14.

杜坤, 郭佳欣, 马紫昂, 毛晶, 凌涛, 赵巍. 中性环境下电催化析氧反应研究进展[J]. 石油化工高等学校学报, 2023, 36(5): 1-14.

Figures/Tables 14

References 92

1	LING T，ZHANG T，GE B H，et al.Well⁃dispersed nickel⁃and zinc⁃tailored electronic structure of a transition metal oxide for highly active alkaline hydrogen evolution reaction［J］.Advanced Materials，2019，31（16）：e1807771.
2	LI J，ZHU Y，CHEN W，et al.Breathing⁃mimicking electrocatalysis for oxygen evolution and reduction［J］.Joule，2019，3（2）：557⁃569.
3	张瑀净，张宝山，孙洁.电解水制氢技术及其催化剂研究进展［J］.石油化工高等学校学报，2022，35（6）：19⁃27.
	ZHANG Y J，ZHANG B S，SUN J.Progress in hydrogen production by water electrolysis and its electrocatalysts［J］.Journal of Petrochemical Universities，2022，35（6）：19⁃27.
4	SEH Z W，KIBSGAARD J，DICKENS C F，et al.Combining theory and experiment in electrocatalysis：Insights into materials design［J］.Science，2017，355（6321）：eaad4998.
5	李志学，杨占旭.共沉淀法制备Co₉S₈/C材料以及性能研究［J］.辽宁石油化工大学学报，2020，40（2）：1⁃5.
	LI Z X，YANG Z X.Preparation and properties of Co₉S₈/C materials by coprecipitation method［J］.Journal of Liaoning Shihua University，2020，40（2）：1⁃5.
6	GUO J X，ZHENG Y，HU Z P，et al.Direct seawater electrolysis by adjusting the local reaction environment of a catalyst［J］.Nature Energy，2023，8（3）：264⁃272.
7	刘梦珊，孟超，胡涵，等.NiMoN催化电极材料的制备及其电解海水制氢性能［J］.石油化工高等学校学报，2023，36（2）：1⁃9.
	LIU M S，MENG C，HU H，et al.Preparation of NiMoN catalytic electrode material for hydrogen production via seawater electrolysis［J］.Journal of Petrochemical Universities，2023，36（2）：1⁃9.
8	MAN I C，SU H Y，CALLE⁃VALLEJO F，et al.Universality in oxygen evolution electrocatalysis on oxide surfaces［J］.ChemCatChem，2011，3（7）：1159⁃1165.
9	DU K，ZHANG L F，SHAN J Q，et al.Interface engineering breaks both stability and activity limits of RuO₂ for sustainable water oxidation［J］.Nature Communications，2022，13（1）：5448.
10	JIAO Y，ZHENG Y，JARONIEC M，et al.Design of electrocatalysts for oxygen⁃ and hydrogen⁃involving energy conversion reactions［J］.Chemical Society Reviews，2015，44（8）：2060⁃2086.
11	GUO C X，ZHENG Y，RAN J R，et al.Engineering high⁃energy interfacial structures for high⁃performance oxygen⁃involving electrocatalysis［J］.Angewandte Chemie International Edition，2017，56（29）：8539⁃8543.
12	ROGER I，SYMES M D.Efficient electrocatalytic water oxidation at neutral and high pH by adventitious nickel at nanomolar concentrations［J］.Journal of the American Chemical Society，2015，137（43）：13980⁃13988.
13	LIU X，INAGAKI S，GONG J L.Heterogeneous molecular systems for photocatalytic CO₂ reduction with water oxidation［J］.Angewandte Chemie International Edition，2016，55（48）：14924⁃14950.
14	DUAN L L，WANG L，LI F S，et al.Highly efficient bioinspired molecular Ru water oxidation catalysts with negatively charged backbone ligands［J］.Accounts of Chemical Research，2015，48（7）：2084⁃2096.
15	BEDIAKO D K，SURENDRANATH Y，NOCERA D G.Mechanistic studies of the oxygen evolution reaction mediated by a nickel⁃borate thin film electrocatalyst［J］.Journal of the American Chemical Society，2013，135（9）：3662⁃3674.
16	XU K，CHENG H，LIU L Q，et al.Promoting active species generation by electrochemical activation in alkaline media for efficient electrocatalytic oxygen evolution in neutral media［J］.Nano Letters，2017，17（1）：578⁃583.
17	CHEN P Z，XU K，ZHOU T P，et al.Strong⁃coupled cobalt borate nanosheets/graphene hybrid as electrocatalyst for water oxidation under both alkaline and neutral conditions［J］.Angewandte Chemie International Edition，2016，55（7）：2488⁃2492.
18	DOYLE R L，LYONS M E G.Kinetics and mechanistic aspects of the oxygen evolution reaction at hydrous iron oxide films in base［J］.Journal of the Electrochemical Society，2013，160（2）：H142.
19	SHINAGAWA T，GARCIA⁃ESPARZA A T，TAKANABE K.Insight on tafel slopes from a microkinetic analysis of aqueous electrocatalysis for energy conversion［J］.Scientific Reports，2015，5（1）：13801.
20	GARCÍA⁃MOTA M，BAJDICH M，VISWANATHAN V，et al.Importance of correlation in determining electrocatalytic oxygen evolution activity on cobalt oxides［J］.The Journal of Physical Chemistry C，2012，116（39）：21077⁃21082.
21	BAJDICH M，GARCÍA⁃MOTA M，VOJVODIC A，et al.Theoretical investigation of the activity of cobalt oxides for the electrochemical oxidation of water［J］.Journal of the American Chemical Society，2013，135（36）：13521⁃13530.
22	LI Y J，CUI L，DA P F，et al.Multiscale structural engineering of Ni⁃doped CoO nanosheets for zinc⁃air batteries with high power density［J］.Advanced Materials，2018，30（46）：e1804653.
23	LING T，DA P F，ZHENG X L，et al.Atomic⁃level structure engineering of metal oxides for high⁃rate oxygen intercalation pseudocapacitance［J］.Science Advances，2018，4（10）：eaau6261.
24	JIN K，SEO H，HAYASHI T，et al.Mechanistic investigation of water oxidation catalyzed by uniform，assembled MnO nanoparticles［J］.Journal of the American Chemical Society，2017，139（6）：2277⁃2285.
25	RISCH M，RINGLEB F，KOHLHOFF M，et al.Water oxidation by amorphous cobalt⁃based oxides：In situ tracking of redox transitions and mode of catalysis［J］.Energy & Environmental Science，2015，8（2）：661⁃674.
26	TAKASHIMA T，HASHIMOTO K，NAKAMURA R.Mechanisms of pH⁃dependent activity for water oxidation to molecular oxygen by MnO₂ electrocatalysts［J］.Journal of the American Chemical Society，2012，134（3）：1519⁃1527.
27	BEDIAKO D K，LASSALLE⁃KAISER B，SURENDRANATH Y，et al.Structure⁃activity correlations in a nickel⁃borate oxygen evolution catalyst［J］.Journal of the American Chemical Society，2012，134（15）：6801⁃6809.
28	BERGMANN A，MARTINEZ⁃MORENO E，TESCHNER D，et al.Reversible amorphization and the catalytically active state of crystalline Co₃O₄ during oxygen evolution［J］.Nature Communications，2015，6（1）：8625.
29	HADT R G，HAYES D，BRODSKY C N，et al.X⁃ray spectroscopic characterization of Co（Ⅳ） and metal⁃metal interactions in Co₄O₄：Electronic structure contributions to the formation of high⁃valent states relevant to the oxygen evolution reaction［J］.Journal of the American Chemical Society，2016，138（34）：11017⁃11030.
30	JIN K，PARK J，LEE J，et al.Hydrated manganese（Ⅱ） phosphate （Mn₃（PO₄）₂·3H₂O） as a water oxidation catalyst［J］.Journal of the American Chemical Society，2014，136（20）：7435⁃7443.
31	LI J，GÜTTINGER R，MORÉ R，et al.Frontiers of water oxidation：The quest for true catalysts［J］.Chemical Society Reviews，2017，46（20）：6124⁃6147.
32	BROWNE M P，DOMÍNGUEZ C，COLAVITA P E.Emerging trends in metal oxide electrocatalysis：Bifunctional oxygen catalysis，synergies and new insights from in situ studies［J］.Current Opinion in Electrochemistry，2018，7：208⁃215.
33	ZHENG X L，ZHANG B，DE LUNA P，et al.Theory⁃driven design of high⁃valence metal sites for water oxidation confirmed using in situ soft X⁃ray absorption［J］.Nature Chemistry，2018，10（2）：149⁃154.
34	KUNIMATSU K，YODA T，TRYK D A，et al.In situ ATR⁃FTIR study of oxygenreduction at the Pt/Nafion interface［J］.Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics，2010，12（3）：621⁃629.
35	SHAO M H，LIU P，ADZIC R R.Superoxide anion is the intermediate in the oxygen reduction reaction on platinum electrodes［J］.Journal of the American Chemical Society，2006，128（23）：7408⁃7409.
36	NAYAK S，BIEDERMANN P U，STRATMANN M，et al.A mechanistic study of the electrochemical oxygen reduction on the model semiconductor n⁃Ge（100） by ATR⁃IR and DFT［J］.Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics，2013，15（16）：5771⁃5781.
37	NAYAK S，MCPHERSON I J，VINCENT K A.Adsorbed intermediates in oxygen reduction on platinum nanoparticles observed by in situ IR spectroscopy［J］.Angewandte Chemie，2018，130（39）：13037⁃13040.
38	YAO Y C，HU S L，CHEN W X，et al.Engineering the electronic structure of single atom Ru sites via compressive strain boosts acidic water oxidation electrocatalysis［J］.Nature Catalysis，2019，2（4）：304⁃313.
39	DENG Y L，YEO B S.Characterization of electrocatalytic water splitting and CO₂ reduction reactions using in situ/operando raman spectroscopy［J］.ACS Catalysis，2017，7（11）：7873⁃7889.
40	LOUIE M W，BELL A T.An investigation of thin⁃film Ni⁃Fe oxide catalysts for the electrochemical evolution of oxygen［J］.Journal of the American Chemical Society，2013，135（33）：12329⁃12337.
41	TRZEŚNIEWSKI B J，DIAZ⁃MORALES O，VERMAAS D A，et al.In situ observation of active oxygen species in Fe⁃containing Ni⁃based oxygen evolution catalysts：The effect of pH on electrochemical activity［J］.Journal of the American Chemical Society，2015，137（48）：15112⁃15121.
42	WANG H Y，HUNG S F，HSU Y Y，et al.In situ spectroscopic identification of μ⁃OO bridging on spinel Co₃O₄ water oxidation electrocatalyst［J］.The Journal of Physical Chemistry Letters，2016，7（23）：4847⁃4853.
43	YEO B S，BELL A T.Enhanced activity of gold⁃supported cobalt oxide for the electrochemical evolution of oxygen［J］.Journal of the American Chemical Society，2011，133（14）：5587⁃5593.
44	SUEN N T，HUNG S F，QUAN Q，et al.Electrocatalysis for the oxygen evolution reaction：Recent development and future perspectives［J］.Chemical Society Reviews，2017，46（2）：337⁃365.
45	KOPER M T M.Theory of multiple proton⁃electron transfer reactions and its implications for electrocatalysis［J］.Chemical Science，2013，4（7）：2710⁃2723.
46	KOPER M T M.Theory of the transition from sequential to concerted electrochemical proton⁃electron transfer［J］.Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics，2013，15（5）：1399⁃1407.
47	GIORDANO L，HAN B H，RISCH M，et al.pH dependence of OER activity of oxides：Current and future perspectives［J］.Catalysis Today，2016，262：2⁃10.
48	FABBRI E，HABEREDER A，WALTAR K，et al.Developments and perspectives of oxide⁃based catalysts for the oxygen evolution reaction［J］.Catalysis Science & Technology，2014，4（11）：3800⁃3821.
49	FANG Y H，LIU Z P.Tafel kinetics of electrocatalytic reactions：From experiment to first⁃principles［J］.ACS Catalysis，2014，4（12）：4364⁃4376.
50	SURENDRANATH Y，KANAN M W，NOCERA D G.Mechanistic studies of the oxygen evolution reaction by a cobalt⁃phosphate catalyst at neutral pH［J］.Journal of the American Chemical Society，2010，132（46）：16501⁃16509.
51	DOYLE R L，GODWIN I J，BRANDON M P，et al.Redox and electrochemical water splitting catalytic properties of hydrated metal oxide modified electrodes［J］.Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics，2013，15（33）：13737⁃13783.
52	HUYNH M，SHI C Y，BILLINGE S J L，et al.Nature of activated manganese oxide for oxygen evolution［J］.Journal of the American Chemical Society，2015，137（47）：14887⁃14904.
53	MCALPIN J G，SURENDRANATH Y，DINCA M，et al.EPR evidence for Co（Ⅳ） species produced during water oxidation at neutral pH［J］.Journal of the American Chemical Society，2010，132（20）：6882⁃6883.
54	KANAN M W，YANO J，SURENDRANATH Y，et al.Structure and valency of a cobalt⁃phosphate water oxidation catalyst determined by in situ X⁃ray spectroscopy［J］.Journal of the American Chemical Society，2010，132（39）：13692⁃13701.
55	KANAN M W，NOCERA D G.In situ formation of an oxygen⁃evolving catalyst in neutral water containing phosphate and Co²⁺［J］.Science，2008，321（5892）：1072⁃1075.
56	KANAN M W，SURENDRANATH Y，NOCERA D G.Cobalt⁃phosphate oxygen⁃evolving compound［J］.Chemical Society Reviews，2009，38（1）：109⁃114.
57	BEDIAKO D K，COSTENTIN C，JONES E C，et al.Proton⁃electron transport and transfer in electrocatalytic films.Application to a cobalt⁃based O₂⁃evolution catalyst［J］.Journal of the American Chemical Society，2013，135（28）：10492⁃10502.
58	TAKASHIMA T，HASHIMOTO K，NAKAMURA R.Inhibition of charge disproportionation of MnO₂ electrocatalysts for efficient water oxidation under neutral conditions［J］.Journal of the American Chemical Society，2012，134（44）：18153⁃18156.
59	YAMAGUCHI A，INUZUKA R，TAKASHIMA T，et al.Regulating proton⁃coupled electron transfer for efficient water splitting by manganese oxides at neutral pH［J］.Nature Communications，2014，5（1）：4256.
60	ZHANG M，DE RESPINIS M，FREI H.Time⁃resolved observations of water oxidation intermediates on a cobalt oxide nanoparticle catalyst［J］.Nature Chemistry，2014，6（4）：362⁃367.
61	BOUWMAN R，FRERIKS I L C.An approach to in situ fourier⁃transform infrared spectroscopic studies of solid/gas interfaces under realistic conditions of temperature and pressure［J］.Applications of Surface Science，1980，4（1）：11⁃20.
62	KATAOKA S，TEJEDOR⁃TEJEDOR M I，CORONADO J M，et al.Thin⁃film transmission IR spectroscopy as an in situ probe of the gas⁃solid interface in photocatalytic processes［J］.Journal of Photochemistry and Photobiology A：Chemistry，2004，163（3）：323⁃329.
63	LI P P，ZHAO R B，CHEN H Y，et al.Recent advances in the development of water oxidation electrocatalysts at mild pH［J］.Small，2019，15（13）：e1805103.
64	LUTTERMAN D A，SURENDRANATH Y，NOCERA D G.A self⁃healing oxygen⁃evolving catalyst［J］.Journal of the American Chemical Society，2009，131（11）：3838⁃3839.
65	YANG L B，LIU D N，HAO S，et al.A cobalt⁃borate nanosheet array：An efficient and durable non⁃noble⁃metal electrocatalyst for water oxidation at near neutral pH［J］.Journal of Materials Chemistry A，2017，5（16）：7305⁃7308.
66	MA M，QU F L，JI X Q，et al.Bimetallic nickel⁃substituted cobalt⁃borate nanowire array：An earth⁃abundant water oxidation electrocatalyst with superior activity and durability at near neutral pH［J］.Small，2017，13（25）：1700394.
67	HAO S，YANG Y C.Water splitting in near⁃neutral media：Using an Mn⁃Co⁃based nanowire array as a complementary electrocatalyst［J］.Journal of Materials Chemistry A，2017，5（24）：12091⁃12095.
68	JOYA K S，TAKANABE K，DE GROOT H J M.Surface generation of a cobalt⁃derived water oxidation electrocatalyst developed in a neutral HCO 3 - /CO₂ system［J］.Advanced Energy Materials，2014，4（16）：1400252.
69	NI B，WANG K，HE T，et al.Mimic the photosystem Ⅱ for water oxidation in neutral solution：A case of Co₃O₄［J］.Advanced Energy Materials，2018，8（11）：1702313.
70	ZHANG Y K，WU C Q，JIANG H L，et al.Atomic iridium incorporated in cobalt hydroxide for efficient oxygen evolution catalysis in neutral electrolyte［J］.Advanced Materials，2018，30（18）：1707522.
71	ESSWEIN A J，SURENDRANATH Y，REECE S Y，et al.Highly active cobalt phosphate and borate based oxygen evolving catalysts operating in neutral and natural waters［J］.Energy & Environmental Science，2011，4（2）：499⁃504.
72	CHEN M Q，XIE Y Y，WU J X，et al.Cobalt （oxy）hydroxide nanosheet arrays with exceptional porosity and rich defects as a highly efficient oxygen evolution electrocatalyst under neutral conditions［J］.Journal of Materials Chemistry A，2019，7（17）：10217⁃10224.
73	GARDNER G P，GO Y B，ROBINSON D M，et al.Structural requirements in lithium cobalt oxides for the catalytic oxidation of water［J］.Angewandte Chemie International Edition，2012，51（7）：1616⁃1619.
74	GRZELCZAK M，ZHANG J S，PFROMMER J，et al.Electro⁃and photochemical water oxidation on ligand⁃free Co₃O₄ nanoparticles with tunable sizes［J］.ACS Catalysis，2013，3（3）：383⁃388.
75	LI R Q，HU P F，MIAO M，et al.CoO⁃modified Co₄N as a heterostructured electrocatalyst for highly efficient overall water splitting in neutral media［J］.Journal of Materials Chemistry A，2018，6（48）：24767⁃24772.
76	MENEZES P W，INDRA A，GONZÁLEZ⁃FLORES D，et al.High⁃performance oxygen redox catalysis with multifunctional cobalt oxide nanochains：Morphology⁃dependent activity［J］.ACS Catalysis，2015，5（4）：2017⁃2027.
77	TAE E L，SONG J，LEE A R，et al.Cobalt oxide electrode doped with iridium oxide as highly efficient water oxidation electrode［J］.ACS Catalysis，2015，5（9）：5525⁃5529.
78	LIU Y W，XIAO C，LYU M J，et al.Ultrathin Co₃S₄ nanosheets that synergistically engineer spin states and exposed polyhedra that promote water oxidation under neutral conditions［J］.Angewandte Chemie International Edition，2015，54（38）：11231⁃11235.
79	KIM H，PARK J，PARK I，et al.Coordination tuning of cobalt phosphates towards efficient water oxidation catalyst［J］.Nature Communications，2015，6（1）：8253.
80	ZHANG X，ZHANG X，XU H M，et al.Iron⁃doped cobalt monophosphide nanosheet/carbon nanotube hybrids as active and stable electrocatalysts for water splitting［J］.Advanced Functional Materials，2017，27（24）：1606635.
81	CAI P W，HUANG J H，CHEN J X，et al.Oxygen⁃containing amorphous cobalt sulfide porous nanocubes as high⁃activity electrocatalysts for the oxygen evolution reaction in an alkaline/neutral medium［J］.Angewandte Chemie International Edition，2017，56（17）：4858⁃4861.
82	WU R，XIAO B，GAO Q，et al.A janus nickel cobalt phosphide catalyst for high⁃efficiency neutral⁃pH water splitting［J］.Angewandte Chemie International Edition，2018，57（47）：15445⁃15449.
83	ROY C，SEBOK B，SCOTT S B，et al.Impact of nanoparticle size and lattice oxygen on water oxidation on NiFeOxHy［J］.Nature Catalysis，2018，1（11）：820⁃829.
84	GAO Z W，LIU J Y，CHEN X M，et al.Engineering NiO/NiFe LDH intersection to bypass scaling relationship for oxygen evolution reaction via dynamic tridimensional adsorption of intermediates［J］.Advanced Materials，2019，31（11）：e1804769.
85	GÖRLIN M，GLIECH M，DE ARAÚJO J F，et al.Dynamical changes of a Ni⁃Fe oxide water splitting catalyst investigated at different pH［J］.Catalysis Today，2016，262：65⁃73.
86	FU H Q，ZHANG L，WANG C W，et al.1D/1D hierarchical nickel sulfide/phosphide nanostructures for electrocatalytic water oxidation［J］.ACS Energy Letters，2018，3（9）：2021⁃2029.
87	LIU J L，ZHU D D，LING T，et al.S⁃NiFe₂O₄ ultra⁃small nanoparticle built nanosheets for efficient water splitting in alkaline and neutral pH［J］.Nano Energy，2017，40：264⁃273.
88	JI X Q，CUI L，LIU D N，et al.A nickel⁃borate nanoarray：A highly active 3D oxygen⁃evolving catalyst electrode operating in near⁃neutral water［J］.Chemical Communications，2017，53（21）：3070⁃3073.
89	NAJAFPOUR M M，EHRENBERG T，WIECHEN M，et al.Calcium manganese（Ⅲ） oxides （CaMn₂O₄⋅xH₂O） as biomimetic oxygen⁃evolving catalysts［J］.Angewandte Chemie International Edition，2010，49（12）：2233⁃2237.
90	UMENA Y，KAWAKAMI K，SHEN J R，et al.Crystal structure of oxygen⁃evolving photosystem Ⅱ at a resolution of 1.9 Å［J］.Nature，2011，473（7345）：55⁃60.
91	BERGMANN A，ZAHARIEVA I，DAU H，et al.Electrochemical water splitting by layered and 3D cross⁃linked manganese oxides：Correlating structural motifs and catalytic activity［J］.Energy & Environmental Science，2013，6（9）：2745⁃2755.
92	JEONG D，JIN K，JERNG S E，et al.Mn₅O₈ nanoparticles as efficient water oxidation catalysts at neutral pH［J］.ACS Catalysis，2015，5（8）：4624⁃4628. （编辑闫玉玲）

催化剂		形貌	pH	电解质	电流密度/(mA· cm^-2)	η /mV	Tafel 斜率/ (mV· dec^-1)	参考文献
Co基	Co⁃Pi	薄膜	7.0	KPi	1.0	410	60.0	[55]
	Co⁃Bi	纳米片	7.0	PBS	14.4	570	160.0	[17]
	Co⁃Bi	纳米片	9.2	KBi	10.0	469	138.0	[67]
	Mn⁃Co⁃Bi	纳米线	9.2	KBi	10.0	366	193.0	[69]
	Ni⁃Co⁃Bi	纳米线	9.2	KBi	10.0	388	142.0	[68]
	Co₃O₄	纳米链	7.0	KBi	1.0	385	70.0	[76]
	Co₃O₄	纳米颗粒	7.0	KPi	10.0	390	-	[69]
	CoO _x H _y	纳米片阵列	7.0	PBS	10.0	430	121.0	[72]
	IrO _x /CoO _x	纳米颗粒	7.0	PBS	1.0	220	29.0	[77]
	CoIr	纳米片	7.0	PBS	10.0	373	117.0	[65]
	Co₃S₄	纳米片	7.0	PBS	起始过电势	310	151.0	[78]
	CoS_4.6O_0.6	多孔纳米管	7.0	PBS	起始过电势	270	164.0	[81]
	Na₂CoP₂O₇	块体	7.0	PBS	1.0	560	80.0	[79]
	Co₂P	纳米颗粒	7.0	PBS	起始过电势	320	129.8	[16]
	Ni_0.1Co_0.9P	多孔纳米片	7.0	PBS	起始过电势	250	133.0	[82]
	Co_1⁃_x Fe _x P	纳米片	7.0	PBS	10.0	500	-	[80]
Ni基	NiCoFeP	-	7.2	KHCO₃	10.0	330	-	[33]
	Ni⁃Bi	纳米阵列	9.2	KBi	10.0	470	107.0	[88]
	Nickel	-	9.2	KBi	1.0	540	57.0	[12]
	NiFeO _x	-	7.0	PBS	10.0	400	-	[85]
	S⁃doped NiFe₂O₄	纳米片	7.4	PBS	10.0	494	118.0	[87]
	NiS _x P _y	纳米线	8.5	KHCO₃	10.0	315	-	[86]
Mn基	MnO _x	薄膜	7.0	PBS	0.1	470	68.0	[52]
Mn基	Mn₅O₈	纳米颗粒	7.8	PBS	5.0	580	78.7	[92]

催化剂		形貌	pH	电解质	电流密度/(mA· cm^-2)	η /mV	Tafel 斜率/ (mV· dec^-1)	参考文献
Co基	Co⁃Pi	薄膜	7.0	KPi	1.0	410	60.0	[55]
	Co⁃Bi	纳米片	7.0	PBS	14.4	570	160.0	[17]
	Co⁃Bi	纳米片	9.2	KBi	10.0	469	138.0	[67]
	Mn⁃Co⁃Bi	纳米线	9.2	KBi	10.0	366	193.0	[69]
	Ni⁃Co⁃Bi	纳米线	9.2	KBi	10.0	388	142.0	[68]
	Co₃O₄	纳米链	7.0	KBi	1.0	385	70.0	[76]
	Co₃O₄	纳米颗粒	7.0	KPi	10.0	390	-	[69]
	CoO _x H _y	纳米片阵列	7.0	PBS	10.0	430	121.0	[72]
	IrO _x /CoO _x	纳米颗粒	7.0	PBS	1.0	220	29.0	[77]
	CoIr	纳米片	7.0	PBS	10.0	373	117.0	[65]
	Co₃S₄	纳米片	7.0	PBS	起始过电势	310	151.0	[78]
	CoS_4.6O_0.6	多孔纳米管	7.0	PBS	起始过电势	270	164.0	[81]
	Na₂CoP₂O₇	块体	7.0	PBS	1.0	560	80.0	[79]
	Co₂P	纳米颗粒	7.0	PBS	起始过电势	320	129.8	[16]
	Ni_0.1Co_0.9P	多孔纳米片	7.0	PBS	起始过电势	250	133.0	[82]
	Co_1⁃_x Fe _x P	纳米片	7.0	PBS	10.0	500	-	[80]
Ni基	NiCoFeP	-	7.2	KHCO₃	10.0	330	-	[33]
	Ni⁃Bi	纳米阵列	9.2	KBi	10.0	470	107.0	[88]
	Nickel	-	9.2	KBi	1.0	540	57.0	[12]
	NiFeO _x	-	7.0	PBS	10.0	400	-	[85]
	S⁃doped NiFe₂O₄	纳米片	7.4	PBS	10.0	494	118.0	[87]
	NiS _x P _y	纳米线	8.5	KHCO₃	10.0	315	-	[86]
Mn基	MnO _x	薄膜	7.0	PBS	0.1	470	68.0	[52]
Mn基	Mn₅O₈	纳米颗粒	7.8	PBS	5.0	580	78.7	[92]

[1]	Jiaman WANG, Jing XIONG, Jinge SHI, Yuechang WEI, Kailing HUO. An Overview of Carbon Dioxide Catalyzed by Titanium Dioxide Catalyst [J]. Journal of Petrochemical Universities, 2024, 37(4): 1-11.
[2]	Lele LI, Lisha SHEN, Zhiming TU, Zhuoxin LU, Hongyi TAN, Yi YANG, Changfeng YAN. Preparation of Cu⁃Doped WN Nanoarrays and Study on Their Hydrogen Evolution Performance [J]. Journal of Petrochemical Universities, 2024, 37(4): 57-65.
[3]	Yanqin BI, Liangliang CHEN, Chunyang DUAN, Zenghua ZHAO. OER Performance of Ce-CoFe-P@CC Nanocomposite Catalytic System [J]. Journal of Petrochemical Universities, 2024, 37(3): 49-57.
[4]	Xuerong Xu, Xiang Peng. Research Progress in Preparation and Application of Layered Double Hydroxides Electrocatalysts [J]. Journal of Petrochemical Universities, 2022, 35(5): 1-11.
[5]	Yang Yang, Chao Meng, Han Hu, Mingbo Wu. Preparation of NiCo₂O₄/Ru Composite Catalysts and Application of Zn⁃Air Batteries [J]. Journal of Petrochemical Universities, 2022, 35(5): 64-70.
[6]	Jian Song, Qiao Han, Zhanxu Yang. Preparation of NiMoP/C Composite Material and Electrocatalytic Hydrogen Evolution Performance [J]. Journal of Petrochemical Universities, 2022, 35(1): 1-9.